Last year, downtown Newark's holidays started outdoors. On the night after Thanksgiving, the Canal Market District held its outdoor Holiday Bazaar from 3 to 6:30 p.m., with 40 local vendors, crafts, food trucks and a Christmas tree. As the bazaar wound down, the 77th annual Licking County Courthouse Lighting began on the square at 6:15 p.m., with a music sing-along and Santa.
The lighting is still the night that opens the season. What has changed is everything around it. The Historic Newark Arcade at 31 N. 3rd St. now hosts the Canal Market District's indoor winter market from November through April. The building also holds a coffeehouse, an ice cream parlor, a beer-and-wine lounge, close to twenty shops and studios, and a new Italian dining room. For the first time, a downtown Newark holiday evening can run for hours with a roof overhead.
A 1909 shopping arcade, back in the role it was built for
The Arcade opened on June 7, 1909, to a design by Carl E. Howell. Newark Development Partners bought it in November 2019. The Newark Advocate reported that it reopened to the public in February 2025, after a cleaning, renovation and restoration that took six years and cost about $20 million. The paper called the building a 1909 enclosed shopping center.
That description matters for the holidays. Newark's December has mostly happened outside, on Courthouse Square and under the open-air canal pavilion at 36 E. Canal St., where the farmers market runs on Fridays from 4 to 7 p.m., May through October. An enclosed arcade was built for walking, browsing and lingering in any weather. A century later, it does that job again.
The project has drawn attention beyond Licking County, too. In March 2026, the Advocate reported that the Arcade had received recognition for its revival, running the story under a headline saying it "gets nod from National Park Service."
The winter market moved in, and the building filled in around it
The Canal Market District's indoor winter market runs from November through April inside the Arcade. The market lists more than 25 vendors, plus up to 22 permanent businesses operating in the building. The market was on its own in its first season: the opening in early 2025 came while several of the planned food tenants were still setting up.
This season, the building around the market is far fuller. The Arcade's shopping directory names these tenants:
- Books, art and gifts: Holland's Book Nook, Licking County Art Association, OhioTRUE, Ball Hill at The Arcade, Marketing & Main, Vintage Legacy, Traveling Gypsy Trade
- Sweets and self-care: The Candy Carousel, Martha's Bath & Body, Beauty Bar 781, Image Salon, Destination Wellness
- Making and playing: Blank Canvas Craft Studio, Couple of Crafty Creations, The Play Connection, Dance Joy Studios
- Boutiques and services: Lady Monarch, Little Arrows, Phone Doctor of Newark
The vendor tables and the permanent storefronts share one corridor, so holiday shopping and the farmers market happen in the same building. If you're picking up baked goods at the market, the bookstore, candy shop and art association are steps away.
Fantuzzo's gives the Arcade a dinner reservation
Food was the last piece. The Arcade's dining page lists The Archive, the Downtown Ice Cream Parlor and Vintage Grind Coffeehouse, with Fantuzzo's marked "NOW OPEN!" It also names VIA and Hudson on 3rd. At the 2025 reopening, the Advocate described The Archive as a beer-and-wine lounge and retailer, Vintage Grind as a coffee bar, the Downtown Ice Cream Parlor as old-fashioned ice cream, and Fantuzzo's as "Upscale Italian dining."
Fantuzzo's took the longest. According to the March 2026 Advocate report, crews started building the restaurant around August of the previous year, after some Arcade businesses had already opened. At the time, Newark Development Partners Executive Director P.J. Sullivan expected it to open within a few months.
It is open now, and it has local roots. In a September 14, 2026, "Aces of Trades" profile in the Newark Advocate, Fantuzzo's Ristorante owner Kara Gallagher talked about growing up nearby: "going to Heath pool," and playing softball "at Hoback Park every summer from the age of 5 to 17." The profile opens with the line that she "loves bringing people together – with food."
Before Fantuzzo's opened, the Arcade's food was coffee, ice cream and a glass of wine. A sit-down Italian dining room is what turns a market stop into a full evening downtown.
The confirmed calendar, Thanksgiving weekend through mid-December
With the Arcade covering shopping and dinner, the rest of the season is built around two fixed points. One is the Courthouse Lighting. The other is the Midland Theatre's holiday lineup.
| Date | Event | Time | Admission |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fri., Nov. 27 | The Nutcracker, Central Ohio Youth Ballet, Midland Theatre | 4 p.m. | $24–$29 |
| Fri., Nov. 27 | Licking County Courthouse Lighting, 1 Courthouse Square | 6 p.m. | Free |
| Sun., Nov. 29 | The Nutcracker, Central Ohio Youth Ballet, Midland Theatre | 2 p.m. | $24–$29 |
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Luminare Christmas! The Ultimate Holiday Rock Concert, Midland Theatre | 8 p.m. | $25–$45 |
| Sat., Dec. 12 | Polar Express, Midland Theatre | 7 p.m., doors 5:30 p.m. | $7 |
| Wed., Dec. 16 | O Christmas Tea: A British Comedy, Midland Theatre | 7:30 p.m. | $29.50–$75 |
Ohio Magazine's listing gives the lighting's start time as 6 p.m., with free admission. It invites visitors to shop the Canal Market's Holiday Bazaar before Santa arrives. Details are on the organizer's site, courthouselighting.com.
The Polar Express showing on December 12 is the low-cost option on the list. Tickets are $7, doors open at 5:30 p.m., Santa is advertised, and Hopewell Federal Credit Union is the sponsor, according to the Midland Theatre. The full holiday schedule is on the Midland's holiday page.
Planning the night after Thanksgiving
November 27 is the busiest date downtown. It's the one day when the Midland, the Courthouse and the Arcade all have something going on. The Nutcracker starts at 4 p.m. and the lighting is listed for 6 p.m., so families can see both. Choose which one sets your schedule, then plan the rest around it.
- Afternoon at the Arcade. Start indoors at 31 N. 3rd St., where the winter market season has begun and the permanent shops are open. Coffee at Vintage Grind or a stop at The Candy Carousel can come before the crowds arrive.
- The 4 p.m. Nutcracker, if it's on your list. Central Ohio Youth Ballet's performance at the Midland costs $24 to $29. If Friday is too packed, the same production runs again Sunday, November 29, at 2 p.m.
- The square at 6 p.m. The Courthouse Lighting is free, at 1 Courthouse Square.
- Dinner after. Fantuzzo's is inside the Arcade. On a night when the whole county comes downtown, it's sensible to plan ahead for a table.
December weekends use the same pattern on a smaller scale
After Thanksgiving weekend, each Midland show can follow the same plan. Dinner at Fantuzzo's before the 8 p.m. Luminare Christmas concert on December 5 is one example. Another is an hour at Holland's Book Nook or the Licking County Art Association before Polar Express doors open at 5:30 p.m. on December 12. The Wednesday, December 16, showing of O Christmas Tea makes a midweek option for anyone who wants to skip the weekend crowds.
None of these evenings depends on the weather the way the old outdoor version did. The Arcade's market season runs through April, so the building stays busy after the decorations come down.
The Arcade's restoration is one of the clearest examples of how a single building can change the way people use downtown Newark, and that shows up in everyday routines and in what nearby blocks are worth. If you'd like a fact-based look at how downtown Newark and the surrounding neighborhoods are changing, Shannon Listebarger can put together a Free Market Report for the part of Newark you care about.