A welcoming village restaurant window table with ivory place settings, coffee and a croissant beside navy seating in soft late-autumn daylight.

Where to Eat in Granville When Family Visits This Holiday Season

Until this year, the first floor of Seek No Further Cidery on East Elm Street was filled with production tanks. The owners have since moved cider production offsite. In the freed-up space they built a permanent counter and opened a café, so a garage-turned-cidery that used to stay quiet until the cider crowd showed up now opens for coffee at 7 a.m. every day.

That counter is a small example of how Granville's food scene has changed over the past twelve months. If you are hosting family for Thanksgiving on Thursday, November 26, or anytime in December, the biggest dinner reservations in the village are mostly spoken for. Most of what's new covers the rest of the day: breakfast, afternoon tea, and the groceries for the meals you cook at home. The best way to plan a hosting week here is to build it around those hours and save the evenings for places that have been on Broadway and Elm for decades.

The Thanksgiving table at the Buxton is already full

The Buxton Inn at 313 E. Broadway reopened to the public in September, as WSYX reported. Its owner, Kevin Showe, bought the inn in March, according to The Reporting Project. Its Thanksgiving Day buffet runs 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. and costs $65 for adults and $25 for children ages 4 to 12, with children 3 and under free. The Buxton's dining page says Thanksgiving reservations are now full. We covered how the inn changed hands in our post on the Buxton's September reopening.

You can still walk in, though. The Buxton's Tavern seats guests first-come, first-served and does not take reservations. That makes it a good place for a drink with a visiting relative on a weeknight in December. The inn has listed a Christmas Day buffet from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. on Friday, December 25, and a New Year's Eve dinner from 6 to 11 p.m. on Thursday, December 31. Menus, prices and reservation details for both are still to be posted. If you want either one, check the dining page regularly and book as soon as reservations open.

Across the street, the Granville Inn at 314 E. Broadway has called itself a Granville landmark since 1924. Its Oak Room lists a Thanksgiving buffet on OpenTable for November 26 at up to $75 per person, for parties of one to eight, with seatings from 11 a.m. through a last seating at 3:30 p.m. Between the two inns, a sit-down holiday buffet on Broadway has a firm window: late morning to mid-afternoon on Thanksgiving Day.

Mornings are where the village added the most

Seek No Further's café is the clearest change for anyone hosting early risers. Co-owners Trent Beers and Garrett Huber founded the cidery in 2021. They told The Reporting Project that the building had gone unused through the middle of the day because "nobody's drinking cider in the middle of the day," and that they wanted a place to meet someone "without feeling rushed." The cidery's own site lists café hours of 7 a.m. to 2 p.m. daily, with coffee from Deeper Roots and pastries from Nellegina's bakery. Since it is open seven days a week, the café works for the Sunday after Thanksgiving too.

Village Coffee Company at 132 E. Broadway has coffee, espresso, breakfast sandwiches, pastries, soups and sandwiches. It is open Monday through Saturday, 7 a.m. to 4 p.m., and closed Sunday. Day Y Noche on Broadway is owned by Mary and Anselmo Morales. Its breakfast menu runs from 8 to 11 a.m. Its posted hours are 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. Monday through Saturday and 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. on Sunday. Here's a simple rotation for a long weekend: the cidery café on Sunday, when Village Coffee is closed, and Village Coffee or Day Y Noche on the other mornings.

The Granville Inn's Oak Room also serves weekend brunch, Saturday and Sunday from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m., according to its OpenTable listing.

The day after Thanksgiving has its own reservation

The newest holiday listing at the Granville Inn is for Friday, November 27. On OpenTable, the Oak Room lists a holiday afternoon tea at 2 p.m. that day for $45, with tea, finger sandwiches, savory bites and pastries. If you have guests staying through the weekend, the tea is a sit-down outing that doesn't compete with the Thanksgiving buffets, and it falls in the middle of the afternoon, after the morning crowd has gone.

For Saturday morning, our guide to Granville's winter market season has the details.

The grocery run looks different this year

This is the first holiday season in about half a century that the grocery at 484 S. Main St. is not Ross' Granville Market. The Ross family ran the store for nearly 50 years and handed over the keys on May 7, 2026. The Saltzman family of Cleveland reopened it as Lucky's Market Granville on Friday, May 22, after fifteen days of renovation, as The Reporting Project reported. The Saltzmans also run Dave's Markets and other Lucky's stores, including two in Columbus. Dan Saltzman is the fourth generation of his family in the grocery business. Anyone planning a Thanksgiving shopping list around the old store's layout should give the first trip a little extra time.

Palumbo's Italian Market at 937 River Road has a handover of its own. Its founders, who opened it in 2012, planned to pass the business to longtime employee and co-owner Kate Wilkinson by the end of 2025, and she told The Reporting Project she did not plan to change the menus or recipes. If your family's holiday weekend usually includes a Palumbo's order, that is the plan the new owner described.

Evenings belong to the places that have been here longest

Once the holiday meals are done, the evenings of a hosting week tend to go to the spots that have been around for decades. Elm's Pizza Parlor at 113 E. Elm St. was opened by the Williams family in 1984, and Tammy Williams is the current owner. Its menu leads with its "famous French bread," alongside pizza, subs, homemade lasagna and spaghetti. Its hours page lists 10:30 a.m. to 10 p.m. on weekdays, 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. on Saturday, and delivery from 5 to 9:45 p.m. For a house full of relatives who don't want to go out again, delivery handles it.

Broadway Pub at 126 E. Broadway has been open since 2005 and serves salads, sandwiches, wraps and burgers. It stays open later than most of downtown: until 10 p.m. Monday through Thursday, 11 p.m. on Friday and Saturday, and 9 p.m. on Sunday.

Three Tigers Brewing occupies Granville's old firehouse at 133 N. Prospect St. It pairs its own beer with Vietnamese-inspired food that goes back to the Mai Chau food truck, which started in 2012. The taproom is open Monday through Saturday from 11:30 a.m. to 9:30 p.m. and is closed Sundays, except for a monthly live-music night. For guests who have had their fill of turkey, it's the most different meal in the village. Harvest Pizzeria at 454 S. Main St. takes orders online and describes its wood-fired food as seasonal and Ohio-sourced.

Whit's Frozen Custard at 226 E. Broadway is open daily from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. It's an easy after-dinner walk from anywhere downtown.

Christmas Eve is the next date to book

The next reservation to plan for is Christmas Eve. The Oak Room lists a $79-per-person prix-fixe dinner on December 24. Starters include soup, pork belly or a pear and prosciutto salad. Entrées include short rib, duck, sea bass or ravioli, followed by a choice of three desserts. With the Buxton's Thanksgiving buffet already full and its Christmas Day details still to come, Christmas Eve at the Granville Inn is the holiday dinner with a fixed menu and price you can book now.

Holiday hours at the smaller restaurants change from year to year. Call ahead before you walk a group of eight down Broadway on the Friday after Thanksgiving, especially at Elm's, Three Tigers, Harvest, Day Y Noche and Broadway Pub.

Sometimes, after a week of coffee at the cidery and pizza from Elm's, visiting family start asking what it would take to live a few blocks from Broadway. When they do, Shannon Lists Homes is glad to walk through Granville's housing market with them, clearly and without pressure. Get Your Free Market Report.

Work With Shannon

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram